A Fine Mess of Indie Craft

In recent days some much anticipated dialog commenced between two heavy weights in the world of crafting.

In this corner… wearing Amy Butler print shorts with a felt owl appliquΓ©, weighing in at over 130,000 Craftster.org members: The Invincible Indie Craft Movement!

And in the opposite corner… wearing art quilt shorts, weighing in at innumerable pounds of ceramic vases displayed on pedestals: The Fightin’ Fine Crafts Establishment!

The exchange began with a conference held by the Society of North American Goldsmiths. Annie, from Imogene, wrote about her experience while attending a lecture entitled β€œD.I.Y., Websites and Energy: the New Alternative Craft”.

Much to her surprise, the speaker did not have very nice things to say. You can read her post here, and don’t miss the comment section, filled with notable reactions from both sides.

This article from Entwinements is also revealing. Here, a fine crafter suggests that the American Craft Council should take us “younger makers” under their wings, and notes, “I’m well aware there will be intense resistance to the inclusions of any of this kind of thing in our current shows, but this is the (much) younger generation, and to ignore them is at our own peril.”

That’s nice, but I think most of us fly just fine on our own, thanks.

I feel this discussion is very relevant to readers of Crafting a Green World. We are all here learning to be resourceful, and make use of things that would otherwise be discarded. In the world’s current state of rampant mass production and depleted resources, this is a noble effort to reduce our footprint through creativity. That’s an amazing concept. Dismissing it as “low craft” (as opposed to “high craft”) is completely ignorant.

You may notice that in the above op-eds, quite a lot of ruckus is made about college degrees and training, as well as criticism of aesthetics. I saw a poster the other day that said “Dissent Protects Democracy”. Does dissent protect creativity as well? Humor me for a minute: What if, years ago, at the beginning of this “new wave” of DIY, the fine crafts establishment had extended their hand in interest and support of the indie community? Do you think they would relax their strict standards for quality craftsmanship in that scenario, or expect us to conform in order to stay in their good graces? It’s interesting to explore the ramifications.

This is an oil and water situation, but shaking the bottle is good.

It makes for a tasty salad.

About The Author

11 thoughts on “A Fine Mess of Indie Craft”

  1. I’ve written about this quite a bit on my blog at lainie.typepad.com/redthread. I support all art and craft; making something yourself is never a bad thing. But I also agree that in the “alternative craft” movement — whatever you want to call it — the level of craftsmanship is often low, and the level of self-righteousness is often high. But it will level out. As new trends come along, people who are genuinely interested in quality craft will stay with it and develop more skill, and probably learn some respect along the way for knowledge and artisan traditions. The rest will move on. This is not the first craft renaissance.

  2. I’ve written about this quite a bit on my blog at lainie.typepad.com/redthread. I support all art and craft; making something yourself is never a bad thing. But I also agree that in the “alternative craft” movement — whatever you want to call it — the level of craftsmanship is often low, and the level of self-righteousness is often high. But it will level out. As new trends come along, people who are genuinely interested in quality craft will stay with it and develop more skill, and probably learn some respect along the way for knowledge and artisan traditions. The rest will move on. This is not the first craft renaissance.

  3. I’ve written about this quite a bit on my blog at lainie.typepad.com/redthread. I support all art and craft; making something yourself is never a bad thing. But I also agree that in the “alternative craft” movement — whatever you want to call it — the level of craftsmanship is often low, and the level of self-righteousness is often high. But it will level out. As new trends come along, people who are genuinely interested in quality craft will stay with it and develop more skill, and probably learn some respect along the way for knowledge and artisan traditions. The rest will move on. This is not the first craft renaissance.

  4. Pingback: Green Craft Blogs We Love : Crafting a Green World

  5. I have been making recycled art for over 15 years. Now it is a movement? Huh?

    I have even taught recycled art lessons (a cross over lesson of making art with recycled goods and a lesson on environmental science).

    Why is it that people think this is something new? It has been around for a long time! We have been recycling long before Al Gore created the internet, ……lol.

  6. I have been making recycled art for over 15 years. Now it is a movement? Huh?

    I have even taught recycled art lessons (a cross over lesson of making art with recycled goods and a lesson on environmental science).

    Why is it that people think this is something new? It has been around for a long time! We have been recycling long before Al Gore created the internet, ……lol.

  7. I have been making recycled art for over 15 years. Now it is a movement? Huh?

    I have even taught recycled art lessons (a cross over lesson of making art with recycled goods and a lesson on environmental science).

    Why is it that people think this is something new? It has been around for a long time! We have been recycling long before Al Gore created the internet, ……lol.

Comments (Keep It Civil...)

Scroll to Top